Page 1 of 1
can anybody demonstrate the pipe creates new instance of cmd, issue?
Posted: 21 Mar 2017 10:49
by taripo
I've often heard that pipes create a new instance of cmd..
I don't see it though
If I go to e.g. the windows directory and I do dir /p | more, then I don't see a new cmd.exe instance appear in task manager.
i'm also interested in when that has ramifications that some might not foresee.
thanks
Re: can anybody demonstrate the pipe creates new instance of cmd, issue?
Posted: 21 Mar 2017 13:45
by aGerman
The new instance is most likely alredy terminated before the Task Manager updated the list. You will need blocking commands. E.g.
Steffen
Re: can anybody demonstrate the pipe creates new instance of cmd, issue?
Posted: 21 Mar 2017 15:17
by taripo
it seems to create two command processes
seems to be creating two cmd processes
So if I open a cmd.exe window, I have one showing in task manager
then I run that and I get 3 running. So it created two.
why?
I notice that pause or pause>nul, doesn't create a cmd process. So it seems like the pipe to set /p=asdf creates two.
Re: can anybody demonstrate the pipe creates new instance of cmd, issue?
Posted: 21 Mar 2017 15:33
by aGerman
That's what Process Explorer shows:

- pipe.PNG (9.64 KiB) Viewed 7318 times
Steffen
Re: can anybody demonstrate the pipe creates new instance of cmd, issue?
Posted: 21 Mar 2017 16:24
by taripo
thanks
Re: can anybody demonstrate the pipe creates new instance of cmd, issue?
Posted: 21 Mar 2017 16:37
by dbenham
You should read the Q&A at
http://stackoverflow.com/q/8192318/1012053.
There are lots of consequences discussed there.
Dave Benham